We have a winner! Drumroll please . . .
Sir Nelson is the top MOCker for this contest, with his "Holy Grail" topping the list:

"In his search for rare minifig shield torsos, Ben disgards the most sacred relic. Bruce and Nate look on...."
Congratulations to Nelson and all of the entrants. Honorable mentions, in no particular order, go to:
eNIGMa 1: Nathan Locking a Post (an Outpost)

Sir Dillon 1: Nate's Barbarians Turn on Him:

Sir Nelson 2: Ultimate Wisdom:

I'll put a more extensive wrap-up of my personal thoughts on my blog.
Bruce