Tolkien's Writings

Discussion of topics concerning life in the middle ages around the world, including architecture, history, and warfare.

Which is the Best?

The Silmarillion
9
21%
The Children of Hurin
1
2%
The Hobbit
16
38%
The Fellowship of the Ring
3
7%
The Two Towers
5
12%
The Return of the King
6
14%
The Adventures of Tom Bombadil
0
No votes
Farmer Giles of Ham
2
5%
 
Total votes: 42

User avatar
Napoleon
Archer
Posts: 394
Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2009 7:05 pm
Location: Vendameria, leading the knights into battle. :P
Contact:

Tolkien's Writings

Post by Napoleon »

Since most of us here are Tolkien fans, I thought this would be a good choice for a new topic. I thought that this would cause some extremely interesting debate. :wink: Please, be polite and stay on topic. :halo: I wouldn't want the topic to be locked.

In case you're wondering, my choice was Return of the King. The Hobbit is good too, as I wrote one of my book reports on it. :D I haven't read the Silmarillion or Two Towers; not because I am lazy, but the Silmarillion at our bookstore is really expensive and I am waiting for a hard-back Two Towers to go on sale, as I don't like paper-backs.
Last edited by Napoleon on Mon Mar 15, 2010 3:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
"There are two powers in this world, the sword and the pen; and in the end the former is always conquered by the latter"- Napoleon Bonaparte

[url=http://z7.invisionfree.com/Teen_LEGO_Fans/index.php?]TeenLEGOFans.com![/url]

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/55680977@N04/]My Flickr![/url]
User avatar
JoshWedin
Chevalier de Chèvre
Posts: 4995
Joined: Sun Nov 09, 2003 2:35 pm
Location: Pondering what you are pondering
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by JoshWedin »

We generally let people discuss such things in "Medieval Life". I'll move it there.

Josh
AFOL and his money are easily parted.

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/ak_brickster/8 ... hotostream][img]http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8252/85336074 ... 2a10_t.jpg[/img][/url] [url=http://www.Brothers-Brick.com]The Brothers Brick[/url]
User avatar
Blue Moon Knight
Archer
Posts: 393
Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 7:12 pm
Location: I'm over here now!

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Blue Moon Knight »

I chose the Silmarillion. Though it's not good plot wise (you probably couldn't make a movie out of it, it just wouldn't be exciting), it really shows you just how much Tolkien built up his world; and that it is an entire world in itself.
With most fantasy books, a world is created, but all we really get is: a map, descriptive details, characters, and various sizes of samplings of the languages/cultures/histories.
The Silmarillion (and his work in general) goes beyond that; with full history, creation myths, calendars, family trees etc, Middle Earth becomes as deep and complex as our own world.
To those who are about to Lego: toss me a few bricks.
User avatar
gormadoc1
Artisan
Posts: 258
Joined: Mon Jan 26, 2009 4:59 pm
Location: Shropshire, England
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by gormadoc1 »

I enjoy all the books yet I chose 'The Fellowship Of The Ring', it appeals most to me as it starts the ball rolling for the Lord of the Rings story.
There can be no triumph without loss,
no victory without suffering,
no freedom without sacrifice.
User avatar
Napoleon
Archer
Posts: 394
Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2009 7:05 pm
Location: Vendameria, leading the knights into battle. :P
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Napoleon »

I love the Children of Hurin, and I'm surprised that no one has picked it yet. I thought it should be up there with Romeo and Juliet and King Arthur! :D It was great.
"There are two powers in this world, the sword and the pen; and in the end the former is always conquered by the latter"- Napoleon Bonaparte

[url=http://z7.invisionfree.com/Teen_LEGO_Fans/index.php?]TeenLEGOFans.com![/url]

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/55680977@N04/]My Flickr![/url]
User avatar
Ye Olde Republic
Marquis of Brique
Posts: 1041
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2003 1:50 am
Location: Calgary Alberta Canada
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Ye Olde Republic »

Napoleon wrote:Since most of us here are Tolkien fans,
Most of us? Where id you get this information? I'm sorry but I really dislike blanket statements like this, that may or may not involve me: A Tolkien not-fan. I'd go so far as to say that I don't like his works at all.
Trevor

Trust me, I think I'm funnier than you do.
Why do I have to add the word "minifig" to my spell checker every time I use it?!

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/old_republic/]flickr[/url]
[url=http://angrylegonerd.blogspot.com/]My blog[/url]
User avatar
Blue Moon Knight
Archer
Posts: 393
Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 7:12 pm
Location: I'm over here now!

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Blue Moon Knight »

Ye Olde Republic wrote:
Napoleon wrote:Since most of us here are Tolkien fans,
Most of us? Where id you get this information? I'm sorry but I really dislike blanket statements like this, that may or may not involve me: A Tolkien not-fan. I'd go so far as to say that I don't like his works at all.
Well that's fine if you don't like it. We'll just put you in the "some members don't like Tolkien" section then. :wink:
To those who are about to Lego: toss me a few bricks.
User avatar
quaraga
Total n00b
Total n00b
Posts: 232
Joined: Mon Dec 28, 2009 4:10 am
Location: roflysst (rolling on the floor laughing, yet still somehow typing)

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by quaraga »

I group the silmarillion with tolkein's son because he more or less stuck together tolkein's stuff into a book. the hobbit is best because bilbo is just so bewildered that he's on an adventure. also in the 2 towers and return of the king, you read all about gandalf and aregorn but then you read the frodo parts and think "why am I reading this?"
-T.R.
He who thinks you should look at the box that says "Quaraga" if you want to find out his username (about as useful to you as his real name). he only wants you to look so he can laugh about you looking there because he's a total smart...
User avatar
Ye Olde Republic
Marquis of Brique
Posts: 1041
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2003 1:50 am
Location: Calgary Alberta Canada
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Ye Olde Republic »

Can I be put at the top of the list please? I'd just like to make sure that such blanket statements don't happen as often as they do. If they are made, there should be some basis/proof. ;)
"Don't label me man." - Hippies
Trevor

Trust me, I think I'm funnier than you do.
Why do I have to add the word "minifig" to my spell checker every time I use it?!

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/old_republic/]flickr[/url]
[url=http://angrylegonerd.blogspot.com/]My blog[/url]
User avatar
ottoatm
Knight Templar
Knight Templar
Posts: 3013
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 4:52 am
Location: New York
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by ottoatm »

Suggest we relax in our outrage over "blanket statements" and enjoy the forum.

This is a friendly forum people, cut people some slack~
Knight Templar
n. pl. Knights Templars or Knights Templar
1.A member of an order of knights founded about 1118 to protect pilgrims in the Holy Land during the Second Crusade.

[url=http://legelot.50webs.com/mainPages/myStory.html]My Lego Stories: The Land of Legelot![/url]
[url=http://z13.invisionfree.com/Castle_World]CW-THE Lego Story Writer's Guild[/url]
User avatar
Blue Moon Knight
Archer
Posts: 393
Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 7:12 pm
Location: I'm over here now!

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Blue Moon Knight »

quaraga wrote:I group the silmarillion with tolkein's son because he more or less stuck together tolkein's stuff into a book. the hobbit is best because bilbo is just so bewildered that he's on an adventure. also in the 2 towers and return of the king, you read all about gandalf and aregorn but then you read the frodo parts and think "why am I reading this?"
-T.R.
Does Christopher Tolkien have his own set of works? I'd never heard of that before. Or do you just mean the Middle-Earth works (like The Silmarillion) that he published for his father?

As far as I'm concerned they are still Tolkiens works, especially The Silmarillion, because he spent his whole life working on them.


Also, I've never experienced that "why am I reading this" feeling. Could you be more specific please?
To those who are about to Lego: toss me a few bricks.
User avatar
ottoatm
Knight Templar
Knight Templar
Posts: 3013
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 4:52 am
Location: New York
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by ottoatm »

Blue Moon Knight wrote:
quaraga wrote:Also, I've never experienced that "why am I reading this" feeling. Could you be more specific please?
Heh heh heh... I can only speak for myself here, (and I love Tolkien), but I do remember thinking this sometimes when I was younger and encountered parts in his books where he would give great amounts of details or back story about something could find significant. :)
Knight Templar
n. pl. Knights Templars or Knights Templar
1.A member of an order of knights founded about 1118 to protect pilgrims in the Holy Land during the Second Crusade.

[url=http://legelot.50webs.com/mainPages/myStory.html]My Lego Stories: The Land of Legelot![/url]
[url=http://z13.invisionfree.com/Castle_World]CW-THE Lego Story Writer's Guild[/url]
User avatar
Napoleon
Archer
Posts: 394
Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2009 7:05 pm
Location: Vendameria, leading the knights into battle. :P
Contact:

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Napoleon »

I am sorry if anyone resented that, but I didn't mean ALL of us. I just meant a lot of us. :) Anyway, keep posting! This is interesting. Even though The Hobbit is good, I am surprised that it is winning, as I figured that either FotR or RotK would win. Oh yeah, I agree that Sil should be considered J.R.R. even though it was edited and published by his son.
"There are two powers in this world, the sword and the pen; and in the end the former is always conquered by the latter"- Napoleon Bonaparte

[url=http://z7.invisionfree.com/Teen_LEGO_Fans/index.php?]TeenLEGOFans.com![/url]

[url=http://www.flickr.com/photos/55680977@N04/]My Flickr![/url]
User avatar
Blue Moon Knight
Archer
Posts: 393
Joined: Thu Oct 02, 2008 7:12 pm
Location: I'm over here now!

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Blue Moon Knight »

ottoatm wrote:Heh heh heh... I can only speak for myself here, (and I love Tolkien), but I do remember thinking this sometimes when I was younger and encountered parts in his books where he would give great amounts of details or back story about something could find significant. :)
Ah, I think I see now. Thanks!
Napoleon wrote: This is interesting. Even though The Hobbit is good, I am surprised that it is winning, as I figured that either FotR or RotK would win.
It may be due to the style of writing Tolkien used. In this case, he used a sort of "third-person-intrusive"
(I don't remember the exact term), which for those who may not know, means that the author basically tends to give their own opinions on the character's actions/thoughts/predicament, while narrating the story.
To those who are about to Lego: toss me a few bricks.
Frank_Lloyd_Knight
Steward
Posts: 516
Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2010 4:53 am
Location: Corpus Christi

Re: Tolkien's Writings

Post by Frank_Lloyd_Knight »

We shouldn't forget about the adventures of Tom Bombadil or Farmer Giles of Ham.
Post Reply