
Thank you...

Okay, my studies from college focused on Central Asia - so.. which names are you refering to? I never really saw much central asia-ness to Tolkien's dwarves.footsteps wrote:Dwarves were drawn from Norse and perhaps a bit of Central Asia. Hobbits reflected rural England.
It was more of an impression on my part. Not so much in the personal names as in place names -- lots of Zs and Ks and such just seemed to have a CA feel to them. As I said, just an impression on my mind.Glencaer wrote:Okay, my studies from college focused on Central Asia - so.. which names are you refering to? I never really saw much central asia-ness to Tolkien's dwarves.footsteps wrote:Dwarves were drawn from Norse and perhaps a bit of Central Asia. Hobbits reflected rural England.
Well, somebody brought up Tolkien, and they found something to quarrel/argue/politely discuss. I guess it was inevitable that I get involved. (For the record, I am a self-styled Tolkienologist-in-training.)footsteps wrote:Tolkien... Dwarves were drawn from Norse and perhaps a bit of Central Asia.
Agreed.Formendacil wrote:I want to point out that the names of the dwarves in the LR and the Hobbit are all authentic, unaltered (except perhaps in the anglicization of the spelling) Old Norse names. Old Norse dwarf names.
Yes, this is what I was thinking about when I made the reference to CA. It was just a wild flyer on my part, trying to cover all bases. But as you say, the similarities probably had more to do with coincidence than with purpose.The language of the dwarves, used among themselves, was not kept deliberately secret at first, but hardly any non-dwarves learnt it. Very few examples of it are to be found, but here are the ones I can think of: Gimli's battle-cry at Helm's Deep (Baruk khazad, khazad ai-menu!), the names of the three mountains above Moria, (see: "The Ring Goes South", I believe), and the dwarven names of Moria, Belegost, and Nogrod (see Vol.s XI/XII of the History of Middle-earth).
Formendacil wrote:
I want to point out that the names of the dwarves in the LR and the Hobbit are all authentic, unaltered (except perhaps in the anglicization of the spelling) Old Norse names. Old Norse dwarf names. This is true for each ever member of Thorin & Co., Gimli, and the dwarves who we know went with Balin to Moria, and every other dwarf mentioned in passing.